Difference between revisions of "Voth"
(New page: The '''Voth''' are an alien of the week race from the ''Voyager'' episode "Distant Origin". They are a typical example of how Star Trek writers have no clue...) |
|||
| (22 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
The '''Voth''' are an [[alien of the week]] race from the ''[[Star Trek: Voyager|Voyager]]'' episode "Distant Origin". They are a typical example of how [[Star Trek]] writers have no clue how [[evolution]] works. The Voth are supposedly the | [[Image:Voth_minister_odala.jpg |thumb|right|A female Voth official.]]The '''Voth''' are an [[alien of the week]] race from the ''[[Star Trek: Voyager|Voyager]]'' episode "Distant Origin". They are a typical example of how [[Star Trek]] writers have no clue how [[evolution]] works. The Voth are supposedly the descendants of an advanced species of [[dinosaur]]s that fled from [[Earth]] to escape the mass extinction event that killed off all of the other dinosaurs. They settled in the [[Delta Quadrant]], where they "evolved" into a very [[humanoid]] species. | ||
Having been space travellers for millions of years, the Voth are technologically quite advanced. | ==Voth Technology== | ||
[[Image:Voth_city_ship_tractors_voyager.jpg|thumb|left|A Voth city-ship captures ''USS Voyager''.]]Having been space travellers for millions of years, the Voth are technologically quite advanced. They have space ships the size of cities, [[transwarp]] drive, advanced [[cloaking device|cloaking]] technology (including personal cloaking devices), [[transporter]]s capable of moving an [[Intrepid-class|''Intrepid''-class]] [[starship]], and computer-cracking technology capable of breaking [[Federation]] [[information security|computer security]] in seconds (granted, given the nearly non-existent computer security seen in Trek, this last ability isn't exactly saying much). | |||
==Culture== | |||
While the Voth are far more technologically advanced than the [[Federation]], they aren't as far ahead as might be expected with a head start of many millions of years. Voth progression is in fact quite slow, largely because of cultural resistance to challenging "Doctrine", a dogmatic and inflexible body of law that defines -- among other things -- acceptable avenues of scientific and technological research. For instance, Voth Doctrine states that the species is native to the Delta Quadrant, and despite ample evidence that they originated on Earth, the scientist who suggested the "Distant Origin" theory was arrested, tried for heresy, and forced to recant. | |||
==Non-Plausibility== | |||
* An advanced civilization of [[dinosaur]]s living on Earth should have left some evidence of their presence that scientists would have found. | |||
* A civilization capable of interstellar travel to escape the [[Cretaceous–Tertiary extinction event]] should have been able to alter the asteroid's course -- preventing the collision from happening at all -- with considerably less effort. | |||
* The Voth are another example of the "genetic destiny" nonsense that permeates Star Trek descriptions of biological [[evolution]]. The ship's computer "extrapolated" the evolution of hadrosaurs by millions of years, resulting in a humanoid form. Such an extrapolation is impossible, since species evolve to adapt to local conditions, not to be more humanoid. The computer could not possibly have known the environmental conditions to which the Voth ancestors were adapting. | |||
==Moral of the Story== | |||
Like many ''Star Trek'' episodes, "Distant Origin" is more of a political statement than a story. In this case, it is meant to demonstrate the obstructiveness and inflexibility of [[creationism|creationists]]. Its success is somewhat undermined by the authors' own poor understanding of evolutionary science. | |||
[[Category: Factions]] | [[Category: Factions]] | ||
[[Category: Star Trek]] | [[Category: Star Trek]] | ||
[[Category: Alien of the Week]] | |||
Latest revision as of 11:53, 21 March 2014
The Voth are an alien of the week race from the Voyager episode "Distant Origin". They are a typical example of how Star Trek writers have no clue how evolution works. The Voth are supposedly the descendants of an advanced species of dinosaurs that fled from Earth to escape the mass extinction event that killed off all of the other dinosaurs. They settled in the Delta Quadrant, where they "evolved" into a very humanoid species.
Voth Technology
Having been space travellers for millions of years, the Voth are technologically quite advanced. They have space ships the size of cities, transwarp drive, advanced cloaking technology (including personal cloaking devices), transporters capable of moving an Intrepid-class starship, and computer-cracking technology capable of breaking Federation computer security in seconds (granted, given the nearly non-existent computer security seen in Trek, this last ability isn't exactly saying much).
Culture
While the Voth are far more technologically advanced than the Federation, they aren't as far ahead as might be expected with a head start of many millions of years. Voth progression is in fact quite slow, largely because of cultural resistance to challenging "Doctrine", a dogmatic and inflexible body of law that defines -- among other things -- acceptable avenues of scientific and technological research. For instance, Voth Doctrine states that the species is native to the Delta Quadrant, and despite ample evidence that they originated on Earth, the scientist who suggested the "Distant Origin" theory was arrested, tried for heresy, and forced to recant.
Non-Plausibility
- An advanced civilization of dinosaurs living on Earth should have left some evidence of their presence that scientists would have found.
- A civilization capable of interstellar travel to escape the Cretaceous–Tertiary extinction event should have been able to alter the asteroid's course -- preventing the collision from happening at all -- with considerably less effort.
- The Voth are another example of the "genetic destiny" nonsense that permeates Star Trek descriptions of biological evolution. The ship's computer "extrapolated" the evolution of hadrosaurs by millions of years, resulting in a humanoid form. Such an extrapolation is impossible, since species evolve to adapt to local conditions, not to be more humanoid. The computer could not possibly have known the environmental conditions to which the Voth ancestors were adapting.
Moral of the Story
Like many Star Trek episodes, "Distant Origin" is more of a political statement than a story. In this case, it is meant to demonstrate the obstructiveness and inflexibility of creationists. Its success is somewhat undermined by the authors' own poor understanding of evolutionary science.